BMW M2 vs Porsche 718 Cayman: UK prices compared

As of 20 November 2026, 65 BMW M2 and 185 Porsche 718 Cayman are for sale at UK specialist dealers. The typical asking price is £46,950 for the BMW M2 and £62,490 for the Porsche 718 Cayman. The BMW M2 sells faster: typically 16 days against 28 days.

The BMW M2 is a compact front-engined, rear-wheel-drive coupé with a straight-six and four seats. The Porsche 718 Cayman is a mid-engined two-seater, sold with turbocharged flat-fours in its lower versions and a naturally aspirated 4.0-litre flat-six in the GTS 4.0 and GT4. They cost similar money, both offer a manual gearbox in many versions, and both are built for keen drivers, so buyers often weigh one against the other.

Side by side

BMW M2Porsche 718 Cayman
For sale now65 at 32 dealers185 at 85 dealers
Typical asking price£46,950£62,490
Cheapest£24,390£31,980
Dearest£99,990£163,495
Typical price against 90 days ago–+56.3%
A year older asks (typically)7% less6% less
Typical time to sell16 days28 days
Sold in the last 30 days1742
Power (bhp, official)365–523296–493
0-62 mph (quickest version)3.8 s3.4 s
Top speed188 mph196 mph
Weight (kg)1,495–1,7801,200–1,420

Asking prices at UK specialist dealers today; time to sell from cars sold in the last six months; factory figures across the versions for sale.

Asking prices over the year

£36k£73k£110kApr 2026Nov 2026
BMW M2Porsche 718 CaymanTypical asking price at UK specialists, checked daily

Asking prices by year

BMW M2

YearFor saleTypical asking
20269£93,995
20255£53,495
202410£49,995
20237£47,250
20221£28,990
20213£64,890
20206£37,495
201911£34,990

Porsche 718 Cayman

YearFor saleTypical asking
20261£64,950
202515£72,900
202416£81,500
202329£76,940
202224£78,950
202113£68,950
202018£72,750
201928£45,980

What they lose with age

BMW M2, one model year older

Asks 7% less

Porsche 718 Cayman, one model year older

Asks 6% less

They hold their value about as well as each other: going by asking prices at UK specialist dealers, a year older, a BMW M2 typically asks 7% less and a Porsche 718 Cayman 6% less. Worked out from asking prices at UK specialist dealers (for sale now, or sold in the last six months): within each version, each model year’s typical asking price against the year before’s, only where both years have three or more cars. As of 20 November 2026.

Which to choose

The BMW M2 suits

The M2 suits a driver who wants a proper performance car that also works every day: rear seats for occasional passengers or children, a conventional boot, and the torque of a turbocharged six-cylinder. The range runs from the original F87 cars through Competition and CS to the current G87.

The Porsche 718 Cayman suits

The 718 Cayman suits someone who wants a two-seater and cares most about balance and steering, with the engine behind them. Buyers who want a naturally aspirated flat-six should look at the GTS 4.0, GT4 or GT4 RS. The four-cylinder cars cost less to buy into and are lighter.

If you need rear seats, or want a car that handles family duties during the week, the M2 makes more sense. If two seats are enough and you care most about mid-engined handling, the Cayman is the more focused car, and the 4.0-litre versions also give you a high-revving atmospheric engine. Within each range, choosing the right version matters more than choosing the badge. An early M2 and a GT4 RS are very different propositions, so compare like with like on year and specification.

BMW M2 for sale, cheapest first

All 65 BMW M2

Porsche 718 Cayman for sale, cheapest first

All 185 Porsche 718 Cayman

Questions buyers ask

Which is quicker, the BMW M2 or the Porsche 718 Cayman?

It depends on the version. The quickest Cayman, the GT4 RS, has an official 0-62mph time of 3.4 seconds, and the GTS 4.0 and GT4 are close to the faster M2s. The four-cylinder Caymans are slower than any M2.

Which is more practical?

The M2. It has two rear seats and a conventional boot. The Cayman seats two, but it has luggage space front and rear, which is useful for a weekend away.

Can you get either with a manual gearbox?

Yes. Many versions of both come with a six-speed manual as well as an automatic or dual-clutch option. The 718 Cayman GT4 RS was sold with PDK only.

Which Cayman has the six-cylinder engine?

The GTS 4.0, GT4 and GT4 RS use a naturally aspirated 4.0-litre flat-six. The standard Cayman, Cayman S, Cayman T and the earlier 2.5-litre GTS use turbocharged flat-four engines.

What is the difference between the M2 Competition and the M2 CS?

Both are versions of the first-generation (F87) M2. The CS is the more focused, limited-production model, with more power, carbon-fibre parts and chassis upgrades over the Competition.

Which holds its value better, the BMW M2 or the Porsche 718 Cayman?

They hold their value about as well as each other: going by asking prices at UK specialist dealers, a year older, a BMW M2 typically asks 7% less and a Porsche 718 Cayman 6% less. That compares like versions, model year by model year, so a newer, dearer version doesn't skew it. Mileage, history and condition matter more on any one car.

Every BMW M2 for saleWhat’s my BMW M2 worth?Every Porsche 718 Cayman for saleWhat’s my Porsche 718 Cayman worth?More comparisons